34 Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes That Will Steal the Show
Nothing rounds out a hearty holiday feast quite like a towering slice of decadent, fresh-baked pie. No matter how full everyone claims to be after the main meal, there is always a magical second stomach reserved exclusively for dessert!
Pie holds a truly special place at our family table. My youngest son, born just two days before Thanksgiving, actually prefers a warm slice of homemade pumpkin pie over a traditional birthday cake every single year.
Whether you are hosting a huge holiday gathering or looking for a cozy sweet treat to bake this weekend, this handpicked collection of crowd-pleasing Thanksgiving pie recipes is guaranteed to bring pure comfort to your table.
Classic Apple Pie
A timeless centerpiece for your holiday dessert spread. Pre-cooking the apple slices beforehand ensures the filling hits that ideal balance of sweet and tangy without making your bottom crust soggy.
No-Bake Apple Pie
Save valuable oven space on busy cooking days with this hassle-free dessert. Featuring a simple two-ingredient graham cracker crust filled with tender, cinnamon-butter sautéed apples, it comes together in just three easy steps.
Sheet Pan Apple Slap Pie
Feeding a big crowd? This easy slab pie layers brown sugar apples over a flaky crust, finished off with a sweet oat crumble topping that makes it an instant autumn favorite.
Apple Cream Pie
Also known as German Apple Pie, this recipe coats juicy spiced apples in rich heavy cream for an ultra-creamy slice that actually tastes even better served chilled.
Apple Cinnamon Pie
Packed with fresh, spiced apples and wrapped in a buttery, hand-woven lattice crust, this show-stopping pie brings traditional bakery warmth straight to your kitchen.
Dutch Apple Crumb Pie
Swap the top crust for a crunchy, brown-sugar crumble! A creamy sour cream apple filling brings a delicious subtle tang to balance out the sweetness.
Apple Pear Pie
Combine autumn’s two best fruits into one dish. Warm cinnamon apples and tender pears rest under a silky brown sugar glaze, making this an unforgettable holiday contribution.
Apple and Blackberry Pie
Tart wild blackberries paired with sweet, spiced apples created under a golden lattice crust. It delivers the ultimate cozy feel for crisp fall evenings.
Traditional Pumpkin Pie
You simply cannot have Thanksgiving without the classic pumpkin pie. Velvety, aromatic, and perfectly spiced, it is wonderfully simple to whip up and begs for a heavy dollop of whipped cream.
Pumpkin Slab Pie
All the warm spiced goodness of a traditional pumpkin pie baked in a large sheet pan. It is designed specifically to feed large family gatherings effortless slices.
Pumpkin Chiffon Pie
Looking to lighten things up? This fluffy pumpkin chiffon filling sits inside a spiced gingersnap cookie crust, offering an airy twist on the usual heavy custard.
Molasses Pumpkin Pecan Ginger Pie
Rich, dark molasses, crunchy pecans, and zesty ginger blend into a spiced pumpkin filling. Nestled in a crunchy gingersnap crust, it is rich enough to serve without any toppings.
Pumpkin Chocolate Pie with Gingersnap Crust
Satisfy pumpkin and chocolate lovers all at once. Warm autumn spices combine with smooth cocoa accents for a surprisingly delicious modern dessert.
Pumpkin Custard Pie
Old-school comfort just like grandma used to make. This easy, nostalgic recipe requires no pre-baking, letting the custard set smoothly into a silky finish.
Amish Pumpkin Pie
Made with simple pantry staples, this traditional Amish recipe brings out authentic, rich autumn flavors with minimal effort.
Pumpkin Coconut Pie
Give your dessert table a tropical upgrade. A spiced pumpkin-coconut custard topped with toasted coconut flakes and candied pumpkin seeds makes every bite exciting.
Easy Cranberry Pie
Sweet, tart, and vibrant red, this pie uses a shortbread crust to complement the bright pop of holiday cranberries.
Cranberry Apple Pie
Sweet apples soften the sharp tartness of fresh cranberries inside a buttery, flaky shell. It looks as stunning on the table as it tastes.
Cranberry Orange Pie
A brilliant holiday pairing that brightens up the dessert table. Tangy cranberries fused with citrusy orange zest create a refreshing contrast to heavy holiday dishes.
Peach Mango Pie
Bring a little sun to chilly autumn days. Juicy peaches and tropical mangoes mixed with cinnamon spices under a crumbly oat topping offer an unexpected crowd-pleaser.
Classic Blueberry Pie
Plump berries baked inside a flaky crust until bubbly and thick. Top with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream for pure bliss.
Blueberry Apple Pie
A wonderful way to bridge late summer and early fall. Frozen blueberries combine with crisp autumn apples for a juicy, fruit-filled center.
Tart Cherry Pie
Sweet-yet-tart cherries baked to perfection, finished off with a light powdered icing drizzle. It brings a bright, classic bakery charm to your feast.
Bourbon Pear Pie
Elegant and aromatic, this pie showcases thin pear slices tossed in warm spices and a splash of bourbon, topped with decorative pastry leaves.
Banoffee Pie
A creamy, no-bake classic featuring a graham cracker base, thick dulce de leche, sliced fresh bananas, and fluffy whipped cream.
French Silk Pie
Silky smooth, light chocolate filling whipped over a crisp crust. It feels like pure luxury on a plate without being too dense.
Chocolate Pudding Pie
A scratch-made Diner classic! Rich chocolate pudding resting on a graham cracker foundation, finished with fresh cream and dark chocolate curls.
Cinnamon Butterscotch Pie
Decadent butterscotch cream paired with a spiced cookie crust. It is entirely no-bake, making your holiday prep completely effortless.
No-Bake Peanut Butter Pie
Smooth, creamy, and effortlessly light. Made with simple, wholesome ingredients, this crowd-favorite pie disappears from the dessert table in minutes.
Old-Fashioned Custard Pie
A simple, timeless egg custard pie that bakes into a silky, golden finish. Comforting and sweet in all the right ways.
Southern Pecan Pie
Sweet, caramelized, and loaded with crunchy pecans. Quick to mix together and pour into a crust for a golden, gooey classic.
Chocolate Chip Pecan Pie
The ultimate holiday treat that takes standard pecan pie to the next level by folding in rich, melty chocolate chips.
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Elevate your pecan pie with a subtle splash of oaky bourbon, creating a complex caramel undertone everyone will ask about.
Brown Sugar Sweet Potato Pie
A cozy Southern staple featuring a scratch-made butter crust, warm brown sugar sweet potato custard, and maple-infused whipped cream.
Looking for More Holiday Inspiration?
- Don’t forget to grab your free meal planning printables from our library to keep your holiday prep organized!
- Be sure to follow along on Pinterest for new festive recipes, seasonal menus, and budget-friendly ideas all year long.
